head to head · open source

ha-mcp vs phonebox

ha-mcp has 7,973 GitHub stars, 470 forks, 13 open issues and last shipped yesterday. phonebox has 2,969 stars, 418 forks, 6 open issues and last shipped yesterday. ha-mcp leads on adoption by 169% (7,973 vs 2,969 stars). ha-mcp is written in Python under MIT; phonebox is written in C# under MIT. ha-mcp has attracted 6% as many forks as stars, phonebox 14%. phonebox was the more recently maintained of the two, and both are self-hostable with no licence fee. The two share 1 topic tag (home-assistant), so they are genuine substitutes rather than adjacent tools.

Two open source projects, one decision. Both are free and self-hostable — the differences are community size, license terms, language stack and release pace.

ha-mcp ★ 8.0K phonebox ★ 3.0K category Miscellaneous

← all 20902 open source comparisons

Side by side

ha-mcp phonebox
GitHub stars ★ 8.0K ★ 3.0K
License MIT MIT
Written in Python C#
Last push 2026-11-18 2026-11-18
Forks ⑂ 470 ⑂ 418
Self-hosting Yes Yes
Data ownership Your server Your server

pick ha-mcp if

  • You weight community size — 8.0K stars and counting
  • You want the MIT license terms
  • Your stack matches Python
  • You value the larger contributor base for long-term maintenance

full ha-mcp profile →

pick phonebox if

  • You want the phonebox feature set and don't need the biggest community
  • You prefer the MIT license terms
  • Your stack matches C#
  • You evaluated both and phonebox fits your workflow better

full phonebox profile →

About ha-mcp

Breaking change (v7.3.0): ha config set yaml has been moved to beta. HA MCP — Manage Home Assistant with AI Configure and automate Home Assistant with Claude, ChatGPT, and other AI assistants. 🚀 Get Started The recommended way to run ha mcp is the HA MCP integration . It installs into Home Assistant through HACS (the built in Marketplace on Home Assistant 2026.11+), runs the full server in process , and works on every Home Assistant installation type — Home Assistant OS, Supervised, Container, and Core — with full feature parity. It is the easiest setup in every case: setup asks for an administrator access…

read the full ha-mcp overview →

About phonebox

PhoneBox English · Türkçe · Deutsch · Français · Español · Italiano · Português · Nederlands · Polski · Русский · Tiếng Việt · 中文 (简体) Turn an old Android phone into a desk panel for your computer. PC stats, AI coding sessions, music and touch controls over USB or Wi Fi. Windows, Linux and macOS. No root, PhoneBox account or cloud service required. Try the live demo · Download · Quick start Example layouts with demo data. PhoneBox pairs a full screen Android app with a small desktop agent . Build your panel in a browser based visual editor: 123 widgets , 30 templates , multiple pages and a live preview. Connect…

read the full phonebox overview →

More in Miscellaneous

Related comparisons

More Internet of Things (IoT) projects

Compare either of these against the rest of the Internet of Things (IoT) field.

Frequently asked questions

Is ha-mcp or phonebox more popular?

ha-mcp has 7,973 GitHub stars and phonebox has 2,969. ha-mcp has the larger community by that measure.

Are ha-mcp and phonebox free?

Both are open source. ha-mcp is licensed under MIT and phonebox under MIT. Neither carries a licence fee.

What is the difference between ha-mcp and phonebox?

ha-mcp is written in Python and phonebox in C#. The practical differences are community size, licence terms, language stack and release cadence — all compared in the table above.

Which should I choose, ha-mcp or phonebox?

Choose ha-mcp if you want the larger community (7,973 stars) or its MIT licence terms. Choose phonebox if its feature set, stack or MIT licence fits better. Both are self-hostable.